Skip to content
American Justice Notebook
Menu
  • Home
  • About The Editor/Publisher
  • Notes – Cases – Thoughts & Quotes
  • Contact’/Subscribe
Menu

Unsealed Arizona police video omits shooting of unarmed man

Posted on May 25, 2016
By CRIMESIDER STAFF
May 25, 2016

Unsealed Arizona police video omits shooting of unarmed man

Daniel Shaver

CBS DALLAS/FORT WORTH

PHOENIX — Video released Tuesday shows officers responding to a report of someone pointing a gun from the window of an Arizona hotel, but a judge barred the release of additional footage showing an officer later shooting and killing an unarmed man at the scene.

The shaky body-camera footage was taken during a Jan. 18 call that ended with Officer Philip Brailsford fatally shooting Daniel Shaver of Granbury, Texas, in Mesa.

Brailsford has pleaded not guilty to a charge of second-degree murder in Shaver’s death.

 

Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Sam Myers ordered portions of the video released after Shaver’s widow and news organizations called for it to be unsealed as a way to hold police accountable and serve the public interest.

However, the order bars the public release of the face-to-face encounter between officers and Shaver until Brailsford’s case is resolved.

CBS 5 – KPHO

Investigators said in police records and in court that the video shows Shaver on the ground outside his room as he is ordered to crawl toward officers and tearfully pleads with them not to kill him. Officers at the scene say they believed Shaver was reaching for a gun.

No weapons were recovered from Shaver’s body. Investigators found two pellet rifles in the hotel room that were later determined to be part of his pest-control job.

Brailsford was later fired for violations of departmental policies.

The video shows Brailsford and other officers getting into a hotel elevator, listening to a sergeant voice a plan for getting Shaver and a woman out of the room, and waiting for several minutes as their calls for the pair to come out went unanswered.

“Listen to my instructions or it’s going to become very uncomfortable for you,” one of the officers shouted.

Officers took cover in doorways as they waited for a response. Brailsford and another rifle-carrying officer at one point crouched down on their knees as they pointed their guns down the hallway.

The edited version of Brailsford’s video ends when someone walks out of the room.

Video taken by another officer ends with an upset woman being taken from the hotel to wait on a bench.

Brailsford, prosecutors and Shaver’s parents have argued that the video shouldn’t be released to protect Brailsford’s right to a fair trial.

Police shooting videos have become the focal point of protests around the country. Chicago officials fought for more than a year to withhold a video showing a teenager getting shot by a police officer, and the court-ordered release of the footage prompted heated protests against Mayor Rahm Emanuel.

NEWS & INFORMATION

THE GUARDIAN CNN NEWS COURTHOUSE NEWS SERVICE THE NEW REPUBLIC HUFFINGTON POST CBS NEWS MSNBC NEWS MEDIA MATTERS FOR AMERICA CENTER FOR PUBLIC INTEGRITY NPR NEWS INSTITUTE FOR FREE SPEECH BBC ROLLING STONE FACTCHECK.ORG

US SUPREME COURT FEDERAL COURT WEBSITE LINKS FBI PRESS RELEASES / MOST WANTED CIA PRESS RELEASES / LIBRARY DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE / PRESS RELEASES FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION: HOW TO HIRE A LAWYER FEDERAL COUNTER TERRORISM GUIDE AMERICAN COURTHOUSE INFORMATION

TODAY'S QUOTE

“The best revenge is massive success.” Frank Sinatra

INVESTIGATIVE JOURNALISM

PROPUBLICA INVESTIGATIVE JOURNALISM REPORTS

“The Founding Fathers gave the free press the protection it must have to bare the secrets of government and inform the people.” – Justice Hugo Black

©2026 American Justice Notebook | Design: Newspaperly WordPress Theme