Skip to content
American Justice Notebook
Menu
  • Home
  • About The Editor/Publisher
  • Notes – Cases – Thoughts & Quotes
  • Contact’/Subscribe
Menu

The Poisoning of the American Media: The Smartmatic v. Fox Corporation

Posted on November 20, 2026

JUST SAYING

Fox News Faces a $2.7 Billion Reckoning as Trump’s Political Fortunes Collapse

JUST SAYING

BY RAUL HERNANDEZ

The Dominion and Smartmatic lawsuits should serve as a warning to the entire news media, especially those outlets on the extreme political left and right that have abandoned journalism in favor of propaganda, poisoning the airwaves with lies, distortions and half-truths.

Journalism is supposed to hold the powerful accountable, challenge falsehoods and provide the public with facts, not manufacture political outrage to satisfy an audience or protect a favored politician.

There is a difference between reporting the news and selling political propaganda disguised as journalism.

The First Amendment protects freedom of speech and the press. It does not provide blanket immunity for knowingly or recklessly publishing defamatory falsehoods.

And that lesson applies whether the political propaganda comes wrapped in a red flag or a blue one.

The press is supposed to be democracy’s watchdog, not a politician’s lapdog.

THE BILL FOR ELECTION FALSEHOODS

Fox News executives might want to reach for their checkbooks before their lawyers reach a jury box.

The network is facing a $2.7 billion defamation lawsuit filed by voting technology company Smartmatic over false allegations broadcast following the 2020 presidential election.

Fox already paid Dominion Voting Systems $787.5 million in April 2023 to settle another defamation lawsuit involving false claims about the election.

Now comes Smartmatic.

The company alleges Fox knowingly promoted false accusations that its voting technology helped steal the election from Donald Trump. Smartmatic contends the broadcasts damaged its reputation and business.

Fox denies liability and disputes the damages.

According to Fox Corporation’s November 2026 SEC filing, no trial date has been scheduled, and a trial is not expected before 2027.

The company’s lawyers insist the lawsuit lacks merit.

Perhaps. But $787.5 million should have taught Fox something about the financial consequences of broadcasting election falsehoods.

THE MIDTERM WARNING SHOT

The November elections delivered a devastating political message.

Democrats captured both chambers of Congress as Republicans suffered major losses across the country. According to Reuters, Republicans lost ground in 99% of approximately 2,200 counties examined in early election returns.

That is a remarkable rejection of the political status quo.

It doesn’t establish how a future jury would decide Smartmatic’s claims. Jurors must evaluate evidence, not punish a television network for its political associations.

But Fox executives would be foolish to ignore the changing political atmosphere.

The anger directed at Trump and his administration could complicate jury selection and public perceptions of the network. That is a litigation risk worth considering, not a prediction of a verdict.

FOX’S AUDIENCE IS SHRINKING

Meanwhile, the network’s ratings are heading in the wrong direction.

According to Nielsen figures reported by TheWrap, Fox News lost 27% of its total-day audience in October compared with the previous year. Its viewership among adults ages 25 to 54 dropped 32%, reaching a 25-year low.

Fox remains a cable news powerhouse, but its aging audience presents a long-term challenge. Younger viewers are not replacing older viewers at the same rate.

Even Fox Corporation CEO Lachlan Murdoch acknowledged viewer fatigue as a factor in declining ratings.

COULD ANOTHER BILLION-DOLLAR BLOW CHANGE FOX?

A billion-dollar judgment is hardly guaranteed. Smartmatic must prove its claims, and any award could face appeals.

Nevertheless, another enormous financial hit would raise serious questions about Fox’s programming strategy.

Would management reconsider the enormous influence of Sean Hannity, Jesse Watters, Laura Ingraham and Greg Gutfeld?

Would the network finally decide that serving as a cheering section for Trump carries financial and reputational costs?

Or would Fox simply write another enormous check and continue business as usual?

Fox executives have a choice between defending the lawsuit through trial and appeals or negotiating a settlement.

The November election results cannot decide a defamation case.

But the combination of declining ratings, a costly legal history and a politically unsettled country ought to give Fox’s executives plenty to think about.

The Dominion settlement cost Fox $787.5 million. Smartmatic is asking for $2.7 billion. At some point, even a television empire must calculate the price of its own programming decisions.

And perhaps the most important lesson is one that every responsible journalist should already understand:

Facts are not partisan. Truth is not negotiable. And a television camera is not a license to lie.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

NEWS & INFORMATION

THE GUARDIAN CNN NEWS COURTHOUSE NEWS SERVICE THE NEW REPUBLIC HUFFINGTON POST CBS NEWS MSNBC NEWS MEDIA MATTERS FOR AMERICA CENTER FOR PUBLIC INTEGRITY NPR NEWS INSTITUTE FOR FREE SPEECH BBC ROLLING STONE FACTCHECK.ORG

US SUPREME COURT FEDERAL COURT WEBSITE LINKS FBI PRESS RELEASES / MOST WANTED CIA PRESS RELEASES / LIBRARY DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE / PRESS RELEASES FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION: HOW TO HIRE A LAWYER FEDERAL COUNTER TERRORISM GUIDE AMERICAN COURTHOUSE INFORMATION

TODAY'S QUOTE

“Everybody is ignorant, only on different subjects.” — Will Rogers

INVESTIGATIVE JOURNALISM

PROPUBLICA INVESTIGATIVE JOURNALISM REPORTS

“The Founding Fathers gave the free press the protection it must have to bare the secrets of government and inform the people.” – Justice Hugo Black

©2026 American Justice Notebook | Design: Newspaperly WordPress Theme